Session Recording vs Heatmaps: Which Tool Fits Your Needs?

published on 27 October 2024

Want to see exactly how people use your website? Here's a quick breakdown of session recordings vs heatmaps:

Session recordings are like watching a video of each visitor using your site:

  • Shows every click, scroll, and page view
  • Captures individual user journeys
  • Best for finding bugs and form issues
  • Takes more time to analyze (2-3 hours/day)
  • Costs $39-299/month

Heatmaps give you a bird's eye view of user behavior:

  • Shows where most people click and scroll
  • Displays aggregate user patterns
  • Best for optimizing layouts and buttons
  • Needs less analysis time (30-60 mins/week)
  • Costs $32-75/month
Feature Session Recordings Heatmaps
Data Type Individual sessions Group behavior
View Format Video replay Color overlay
Time to Results Immediate 1-2 weeks
Storage Needs High (1TB+) Low (100GB+)
Best For Bug fixing, form analysis Layout testing, CTA placement

Most companies get better results using both tools together. For example, Flos USA increased checkout conversions by 125% by using heatmaps to spot problems and recordings to see exactly how users got stuck.

Top tools to try:

What is Session Recording?

Session recording lets you watch how visitors use your website. Think of it like a DVR for your website - you see every click, scroll, and page view.

Action Type Desktop Mobile
Mouse Movement -
Clicks/Taps
Scrolling
Page Navigation
Form Fills
Error Messages

How Session Recording Works

Here's something most people don't know: It's NOT actually recording video. Instead, a small code snippet tracks each user action and rebuilds them into a replay later.

Main Features

Feature What It Shows
User Path Pages visited in order
Interaction Maps Where users click and move
Form Analytics How users fill out forms
Error Tracking When users hit problems
Device Info Desktop/mobile usage data

What Can You Do With It?

Companies use session recordings to:

  • Find and fix bugs FAST (Audiense spotted a broken password validator this way)
  • Improve forms (re:member got 17% more conversions)
  • Help customers better (support sees exactly what went wrong)
  • Check if new features work
  • Spot UX problems

Getting Started

You'll need these 3 things:

  • Access to add code to your website
  • Space to store recordings
  • User permission settings

Behind the Scenes

The tracking code watches:

  • Browser events
  • HTML changes
  • User inputs
  • Network requests

Privacy first: These tools automatically hide sensitive stuff like passwords and payment details. They follow GDPR and CCPA rules.

Quick tip: Don't get overwhelmed. Just 10-20 recordings can show you the biggest issues hitting your conversion rates.

What are Heatmaps?

Heatmaps are like weather maps for your website. They show where users click, scroll, and move using colors - red for high activity, blue for low activity.

Here's how the colors work:

Color Meaning Activity Level
Red/Orange High activity Most clicks/views
Yellow Medium activity Some engagement
Green/Blue Low activity Minimal interaction

Different Heatmap Types

Type What It Shows Use Case
Click Maps Where users click/tap Find if CTAs work
Scroll Maps How far users scroll Check content reach
Move Maps Mouse movement paths Track user attention
Rage Click Maps Repeated rapid clicks Spot user frustration

Getting Started

Want to use heatmaps? Here's what to do:

  1. Pick your tool: Choose heatmap software
  2. Install tracking: Add the code to your site
  3. Select pages: Choose which pages to monitor
  4. Collect data: Give it 1-2 weeks
  5. Review results: Look at desktop and mobile separately

What to Look For

When you check your heatmaps, focus on:

  • Cold spots: Blue areas where nobody clicks
  • Hot areas: Red sections getting lots of attention
  • Scroll patterns: Where people stop reading
  • Device behavior: Desktop vs mobile differences

Here's something interesting: Users spend 57% of their time looking at content above the fold (Nielsen Norman Group study). That's why you need your best content up top.

"We ran a series of A/B tests based on the data we gathered by using Heatmaps, Scrollmaps, and Surveys available on the VWO Platform. It helped us identify key elements on our websites that needed a deeper look." - Ubisoft team

Quick tip: Always check both desktop AND mobile heatmaps. People use these devices in completely different ways.

One last thing: Don't rush into changes. Give your heatmaps time to collect enough data first.

Tools Side by Side

Here's how session recording and heatmap tools stack up against each other:

How Each Tool Gets Data

Feature Session Recording Heatmaps
Data Type Individual user actions Aggregated user behavior
Collection Method Video-like recordings Color-coded overlays
Storage Impact High (full session data) Low (summarized data)
Privacy Level Higher risk (individual data) Lower risk (grouped data)

System Requirements

Component Session Recording Heatmaps
Server CPU 8 cores 4 cores
RAM 16-32 GB 8-16 GB
Storage 1 TB+ 100-500 GB
Browser Support Modern browsers All browsers

Setup Time

Here's what you'll need based on popular tools:

Tool Setup Steps Time to Install
Hotjar Add single code snippet 5-10 minutes
Mouseflow Install plugin 2-5 minutes
Smartlook Add tracking code 5-15 minutes
Microsoft Clarity Copy/paste code 5 minutes

Analysis Time Investment

Analysis Type Session Recording Heatmaps
Quick Check 15-30 mins/session 5-10 mins/page
Deep Analysis 2-3 hrs/multiple sessions 30-45 mins/page
Data Collection Instant results 1-2 weeks

Storage Limits

Tool Storage Period Data Limits
Microsoft Clarity 30 days No limit
Hotjar 12 months Plan-based
CrazyEgg 12-24 months 30,000-500,000 views
Mouseflow 1-12 months 1,000-500,000 sessions

"We found that session recordings require about 15 hours of recording per GB of storage space, which is why we recommend at least 1 TB of shared or local drive space for active users." - Microsoft's Session Recording documentation

Bottom Line: Session recordings eat up more space but show exactly what users do. Heatmaps need less storage but take time to build useful patterns. For pricing context: Hotjar's $39/month plan gives you 3,000 sessions, while Smartlook offers 5,000 sessions at $55/month.

When to Pick Session Recording

Here's what you need to know about using session recording tools:

Best Uses

Use Case Why It Works
Bug Detection See exactly how errors happen
Form Analysis Find out why users quit forms
Checkout Issues Spot where buyers leave
New Features Watch how people use updates
Support Cases Fix user problems faster

Business Types

Business Type Main Benefits
E-commerce See shopping and cart behavior
SaaS Products Check onboarding success
Online Services Find booking roadblocks
B2B Platforms Map complex user paths
Subscription Sites See why people convert

Team Skills

Role Required Skills
Analysts Spot patterns in data
UX Designers Know user behavior basics
Developers Debug code issues
Product Managers Map user flows
Support Teams Solve user problems

Cost Breakdown

Factor Impact on Budget
Storage Space 15 hours recording/GB
Monthly Sessions $39-55 for 3,000-5,000 sessions
Team Size Pay per user
Retention Period More storage costs more
Integration Needs Extra for API access

Tech Needs

Component Minimum Specs
Server 8+ CPU cores
Memory 16-32 GB RAM
Storage 1+ TB space
Browser Support Modern browsers only
Integration JavaScript snippet

"Session recordings show you exactly what visitors do, so you can make changes based on facts, not guesses." - VWO

Here's what companies achieved with session recording:

  • Flos USA fixed their checkout and got 125% more conversions
  • PayU removed extra form fields and boosted checkouts by 6%
  • Plutio fixed their mobile menu to stop page refresh issues

Bottom line: Use session recording when you want to see exactly what users do. Make sure you have enough storage and team members who can watch and learn from the recordings.

When to Pick Heatmaps

Here's what you need to know about using heatmaps for your website:

Purpose How Heatmaps Help
Layout Testing Shows where users look most
CTA Placement Reveals which buttons get clicks
Content Analysis Shows scroll depth patterns
Navigation Check Highlights menu problems
Mobile Design Shows how devices differ

Want better sales? Here's how heatmaps help specific business needs:

Goal Heatmap Solution
Boost Sales Find prime spots for products
Cut Drop-offs Spot exit points
Fix Forms See form completion
Improve CTAs Test button spots
Mobile Sales Check phone usage

Your team needs these skills:

Role Key Skills
UX Designer Read heat patterns
Data Analyst Spot user trends
Web Developer Set up tracking
Product Manager Guide changes
Marketing Team Place content

Here's what you'll need:

Resource Details
Storage 500MB - 1GB monthly
Processing Basic web server
Time 2-3 weeks data collection
Staff 1-2 hours weekly
Budget $29-99 per month

Tech basics:

Item Requirements
Code JavaScript snippet
Browser Chrome, Firefox, Safari
Speed < 1 second load
SSL HTTPS needed
Cache Browser storage

"At Spotahome, heatmaps help our team spot and fix UX issues together" - Sara Parcero-Leites, Customer Knowledge Manager

Look at these results:

  • Bear Mattresses: 24% more sales in 19 days
  • Materials Market: £10,000 more yearly income
  • Netflix: Better content matches for viewers

Bottom line: Teams that use heatmaps get 16% better test results (based on 127,000 experiments).

Privacy Rules and Laws

Here's what you need to know about data privacy for session recordings and heatmaps:

Law Key Requirements Fines
GDPR (EU) User consent, data transparency Up to €20M or 4% revenue
CCPA (California) Data disclosure, opt-out option $2,500-7,500 per violation
LGPD (Brazil) Explicit consent, data rights 2% revenue up to R$50M
POPI (South Africa) Data protection, user rights Up to R10M

Data Collection Rules

Data Type Collection Requirements
Personal Info Written consent needed
Session Data Clear notice required
Mouse Moves Must be anonymized
Form Inputs Mask sensitive fields
IP Addresses Store securely, encrypt

Want to collect user data? Here's what your cookie banner MUST show:

Required Info Details to Include
Data Types What you collect
Purpose Why you need it
Storage Where data goes
Duration How long kept
Third Parties Who sees data

Data Storage Rules

Here's how long you can keep different types of data:

Data Type Max Storage Time
Session Recordings 30-90 days
Heatmap Data 6-12 months
User Consent 2 years
Analytics 14-25 months
Financial Data 7 years

GDPR Rules

Here's what GDPR demands from your tracking tools:

Requirement How to Meet It
Data Access Let users see their data
Data Delete Add deletion option
Data Export Provide download tool
Data Limits Set auto-deletion
Data Security Use encryption

Storage Time by Business Type

Different businesses need different storage periods:

Business Type Storage Period Reason
E-commerce 2-3 years Order history
SaaS 1-2 years Usage patterns
Media 6-12 months Content trends
B2B 3-5 years Sales cycles
Healthcare 6+ years Legal rules

Pro tip: Tools like Zipy can mask personal info in recordings and block sessions from specific countries or IPs.

"The CPRA limits data retention to what's necessary and proportionate to the reason it was collected" - California Privacy Protection Agency, 2023 Guidelines

Key takeaways for data storage:

  • Delete session recordings after analysis
  • Keep only needed heatmap data
  • Remove user IDs from reports
  • Check local laws for limits
  • Document deletion dates

Working with Other Tools

Here's how these tools connect and work together to help you track what users do on your site.

Analytics Platform Integration Features
Google Analytics - Event filtering for heatmaps
- Segment data by GA events
- Track low-performing pages
Mixpanel - User behavior tracking
- Custom event mapping
- Funnel analysis
Segment - Data routing
- Cross-platform tracking
- User identification

API and Export Options

Tool What You Can Do
Mouseflow - Connect with 127 tools
- Use custom API
- Get data in real-time
Hotjar - Use REST API
- Set up webhooks
- Export your data

Want to save your data? Here's what you can export:

  • Heatmaps as CSV, JSON, or PDF files
  • Session recordings as MP4 videos
  • Raw data through API feeds
  • Custom reports for your team

Connect With Your Tools

These tools work with:

  • Online Stores: Shopify, WooCommerce, Magento
  • Website Builders: WordPress, Drupal, Joomla
  • Marketing Tools: HubSpot, Optimizely, Slack

Team Features

Your team can:

  • Add comments to hotspots
  • Share dashboards
  • Get alerts via email or Slack
  • Create custom charts
  • Track trends over time

"In this step-by-step guide, we'll explore how to leverage the synergy between these two powerful instruments to gain unique insights into how visitors interact with your web assets." - Berglind Jónsdóttir, Senior UX Designer at Mouseflow

Quick Setup Steps:

  • Connect GA events to filter heatmap data
  • Turn on Slack notifications
  • Set up Hotjar's Highlights for team feedback
  • Add webhook triggers
  • Schedule regular data exports
sbb-itb-0e7f3ec

Price Comparison

Here's what session recording and heatmap tools cost:

Tool Type Free Options Entry-Level Paid Plans
Session Recording Microsoft Clarity, Browsee TWIPLA ($12.99/mo), Smartlook ($19/mo)
Heatmaps Hotjar Basic (35 sessions/day) Hotjar Plus (€32/mo, 100 sessions/day)
Combined Tools Hotjar (2,000 pageviews/day) Mouseflow (£31/mo)

Want more features? Here's what you'll pay based on your site size:

Usage Level Tool Options Monthly Cost
Small Sites Lucky Orange, VWO $39-49
Medium Sites FullStory, LogRocket $166-280
Large Sites Contentsquare, Glassbox $4,167-10,000

Your data storage options:

Plan Type Data Retention Storage Limit
Free Plans 30-90 days Limited sessions
Basic Paid 1 year Up to 500k actions
Premium 2+ years Millions of actions

Team pricing looks like this:

Team Size Cost Range Features
1-5 users $39-89/mo Basic access
6-10 users $89-299/mo Team features
Enterprise Custom pricing Unlimited users

As your site grows, two main factors affect your costs:

  1. Traffic: More visitors = higher price
  2. Features: Basic recording costs less than full analytics

Here's what to expect as you scale:

Traffic Level Monthly Sessions Price Range
Startup Up to 100k $29-89
Growing 100k-500k $89-299
Enterprise 500k+ $999+

For big companies, tools like Google Analytics 360 start at $50,000/year and can go up to $150,000+ with extras.

Making Your Choice

Here's how to pick between session recordings and heatmaps based on what actually works.

Core Differences

Factor Session Recordings Heatmaps
Daily Time 2-3 hours analysis 30-60 mins weekly
Data Type Individual sessions Group behavior
Privacy More sensitive Less sensitive
Storage 1GB per 1k sessions 100MB per heatmap
Team 2+ people needed 1 person can handle

When to Use Each Tool

Session recordings work best when you need to:

  • Find checkout problems
  • Watch form completions
  • Track exact user paths

Heatmaps make sense for:

  • Testing layouts
  • Measuring CTA performance
  • Understanding scroll depth

What You'll Need

Need Session Recordings Heatmaps
Storage 1TB+ (mid-size site) 100GB+ (mid-size site)
Skills Video analysis Data visualization
Tools Video + analytics Basic analytics
Cost $39-299/month $32-75/month

Timeline to Results

Step Time
Install 30 mins
Get Data 2-4 weeks
Train Team 3 hours
First Results 1-2 weeks

Real Results

"VWO's tools helped Flos USA boost checkout conversions by 125%. Their ROI? 18X after fixing checkout issues." - VWO Case Study

PayU's story? They cut unnecessary form fields after watching session recordings. Result: 6% more checkouts.

Here's what works best for common goals:

Goal Tool Choice Timeline
Fix UX Session recordings 1-2 months
Better CTAs Heatmaps 2-3 weeks
More Sales Both 3-4 months
Bug Fixes Session recordings 1-2 weeks
New Layouts Heatmaps 2-4 weeks

Using Both Tools

Here's how heatmaps and session recordings work together to boost your website's performance:

Benefit How It Works
User Journey Heatmaps show where users click, recordings show why
A/B Testing Heatmaps point to problems, recordings explain user behavior
Bug Detection Heatmaps highlight issues, recordings show exact steps
Revenue Impact Heatmaps track engagement, recordings show conversion paths

Getting Started

1. Add Your Tracking Code

Just one code snippet handles both tools. Most platforms do this automatically.

2. Choose Your Pages

Focus on these key areas:

Page What to Track
Homepage Both heatmaps and recordings
Products Start with heatmaps
Checkout Focus on recordings
Forms Watch recordings closely
Landing Pages Use both tools

3. Set Your Limits

Keep costs in check:

  • Heatmaps: 100MB per map
  • Recordings: 1GB per 1,000 sessions

Making Sense of Your Data

Look At What It Tells You
Clicks Compare hot spots to actual clicks
Scrolling Check scroll maps vs. video data
Forms Link heat data to error recordings
Exit Points Match exit clicks to final actions

Daily Workflow

Morning (30 mins)

  • Check heatmap patterns
  • Watch 2-3 recordings
  • List issues to fix

Weekly (2 hours)

  • Look at heatmap trends
  • Study 10-15 recordings
  • Update your settings

Resource Planning

Need Monthly Amount
Storage 1TB
Team Hours 15-20
Analysis Time 2-3 hours/day
Reporting Weekly

"VWO's tools helped Flos USA boost checkout conversions by 125%. We used heatmaps to spot problem areas and recordings to see exactly how users got stuck." - VWO Case Study

Quick Tip: Use Hotjar's filters to match heatmaps with specific user groups based on job titles or locations.

Conclusion

Here's what the data tells us about session recordings vs. heatmaps:

Tool Type Best For Time Investment Results Example
Session Recordings Finding UX issues, bug tracking 2-3 hours/day JellyTelly: 105% increase in sign-up page visits
Heatmaps Page layout optimization, CTA placement 15-20 hours/month Paltalk: 11.32% boost in conversions
Combined Approach Full user behavior analysis 25-30 hours/month Flos USA: 125% checkout conversion increase

Session recordings work best when you need to:

  • See how users move through your site
  • Spot bugs and errors
  • Figure out form problems
  • See what mobile users do

Heatmaps shine when you want to:

  • Test different layouts
  • Find the best spot for buttons
  • See how far people scroll
  • Understand where people click

Here's what to think about before picking a tool:

Factor Questions to Ask
Budget What's your monthly tool spend limit?
Team Size Who will analyze the data?
Storage How much data will you keep?
Tech Stack What other tools need integration?
Time How many hours can you spend on analysis?

"VWO's tools helped Flos USA boost checkout conversions by 125%. We used heatmaps to spot problem areas and recordings to see exactly how users got stuck." - VWO Case Study

The bottom line? Most companies get better results using BOTH tools together. This combo helps you catch issues one tool might miss and gives you the full picture of how people use your site.

Want the best results? Set clear goals, track the right data, check it often, make changes based on what you find, and test to see if those changes worked.

FAQs

What are the benefits of heatmaps?

Heatmaps show exactly how people use your website through easy-to-read visual data.

Here's what heatmaps tell you:

Benefit What You Learn Example Result
Click Patterns Where users click most PayU cut their email field, boosting checkouts 6%
Scroll Depth How far people read Flos USA found 40% of users missed product details
User Focus What catches attention VWO saw CTAs above fold get 3x more clicks
Ad Spots Best places for ads Hot zones show prime ad locations

The big plus? You spot problems in SECONDS instead of drowning in analytics data.

Take PayU's success story:

  • They watched where users got stuck
  • Cut out extra form fields
  • Tracked behavior changes
  • Measured conversion lifts

"VWO's heatmaps showed us exactly where customers struggled in checkout. After fixing these spots, our conversion rate jumped 125%." - Flos USA Case Study

But here's what's cool: heatmaps work even better with other tools. Flos USA proved this by mixing heatmaps with session recordings - and got 18X ROI from the fixes they made.

Related posts

Read more